Posts

Silva v. RBC

There's a decision out of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice that garnered some attention earlier this year, Silva , with a wrongful dismissal action resulting in a judgment in excess of $2.5 million against RBC. The Employment Relationship Ms. Silva was a 47-year-old financial planner with about 11.5 years of service with RBC, from 2006 to 2018. For most of her employment, she was a top performer who was very successful in her role, building a $150M book of business. In October 2016, following discussions with RBC, Silva transferred from the Ajax branch to Richmond Hill, closer to where she lived. Both Silva and RBC were optimistic about the prospects of this transition. However, her compensation was heavily commission-influenced, and so the transition of her book of business became a bit of a sticking point - RBC wanted her to gradually transition her Ajax clients to other financial planners over the next 12-18 months, while building a portfolio in Richmond Hill. However, she ...

"At any time" - Ontario Court of Appeal overturns Baker and Li

  Last year, I commented on a growing issue in Ontario where employment contracts permitting the employer discretion to terminate "at any time" were seen as non-compliant with employment standards legislation. I suggested that, at least in the Ontario context, there was a good argument that this was an incorrect read of the statutory construction. Last week, the Ontario Court of Appeal addressed the issue in Baker v. Van Dolder  and Li v. Wayfair , overturning the approach adopted by the lower courts: The language of "at any time" doesn't appear "to render legally effective a termination that is expressly prohibited by the ESA ." However, I have some comments on the analysis adopted by the ONCA here. Li's contract went a step beyond "at any time", into "at any time and for any reason". In my view, that would be problematic on a principled perspective, as there absolutely are  reasons for which an employer is not entitled to ter...

Repudiating the Employment Contract by Suing your Employer

One of my pet peeves in this area of law is the inconsistent treatment of the question of "Can the employment relationship persist during litigation?" This tends to be answered differently depending on who is taking what position. I've written about this issue before . The most recent case on the matter is a BC decision, Adrain v. Agricom , where the employer had provided 13 months of working notice to an employee with about 30 years of service. She was entitled to reasonable notice in the amount of 24 months - a point that was conceded by trial. She hired a lawyer to try to negotiate a package, highlighting that she's entitled to more than the 13 months' notice that had been provided, and asking for a commitment to pay the additional notice entitlements. The employer appeared unwilling to enter into negotiations with the employee's lawyer, so a statement of claim was filed. At the outset, a few observations: Her lawyer was right. The employer's notice was...

Constructive Dismissal Damages and the Alberta Public Service Act

In the case of Twilley v. Alberta , a dismissed government employee challenged the applicability of a statutory pay-in-lieu-of-notice framework to constructive dismissal scenarios. In reaching its decision, unfortunately, the Court of King's Bench relied on propositions from the Alberta Court of Appeal that are, inarguably, no longer good law . Not entirely the Court's fault; the unsuccessful Applicant relied on those same propositions. Legal Background In 2019, the newly-elected UCP government amended the Public Service Act  to fix the amount of notice or pay in lieu of notice that dismissed employees would receive, by adding s.25.01. (3)   Notwithstanding any right existing at common law, an employee who is terminated without cause is entitled to a period of notice of termination no greater than the following:                           ...

Yee v. Westjet - A Human Rights Analysis Gone Wrong

A few months ago, the Alberta Court of Justice decided a wrongful dismissal case in Yee v. WestJet . It's an antivax case with a number of analytical problems. The short version of the facts is that, in response to Federal government mandates, WestJet implemented a vaccine policy. Yee sought an exception under the policy on the basis of 'religious convictions', and WestJet denied the request, and dismissed the employee upon the failure to comply with the policy. The court concluded that the policy was properly implemented, but that WestJet failed to accommodate Yee, and therefore wrongfully dismissed her. I've expressed concerns before about how the courts deal with an employer's ability to implement vaccine mandates . In this context, faced with direct regulatory action requiring such a policy, I'm less concerned. But the outcome here troubles me in several ways. The court's analysis of the jurisdictional question is problematic; it drew conclusions on the ...