General Billposting: A Rule in Doubt
In 2011, the Alberta Court of Appeal decided the case of Globex Foreign Exchange Corporation v. Kelcher , dealing with the enforceability of non-competition agreements under certain circumstances. Two of the defendants, Kelcher and Oliveiro, had entered into these non-comps during the course of their employment relationships, without any 'fresh consideration'. The third, MacLean, entered into it at the commencement of his employment relationship. MacLean was wrongfully dismissed; he entered into competition with Globex, and Kelcher and Oliveiro resigned their positions to join him. The absence of fresh consideration made Kelcher's and Oliveiro's agreements unenforceable; this issue has been explored indepth in the Ontario appellate case law, and the majority of the Alberta Court of Appeal decided to follow the Ontario jurisprudence. (Justice Slatter, in dissent, argued that the Ontario case law gets it wrong.) However, the question of MacLean's agreement wa...